Prop vs. Jet; The Venezuelan Example

March 5, 2021

*TRANSCRIPT*

If you have an interest in military aviation history you have probably come across the topic of “How would a propellor fighter – say one from World War Two – do against a modern jet?” It seems to crop up periodically and leads to all sorts of speculation.

You will hear that maybe the prop fighter, slower but more agile, will be able to evade the modern aircraft and that perhaps with its lower heat signature things like heat seeking missiles won’t be able to lock onto it.

And there are cases of prop aircraft getting the better of jet aircraft with much better performance than them, principally in Korea and Vietnam.

But with modern fighters, there are two problems with the scenario.

Firstly, modern heat seekers are unbelievably sensitive, they have no problem locking onto piston engines.

Secondly, no matter how agile the prop aircraft is, a modern jet is quite capable of getting onto it for a gun kill down just off the dirt.

We know this because it has happened.

In 1992 two coups were launched in Venezuela against the President, Carlos Andrés Pérez, who had become unpopular due to enacting spending cuts that had pushed prices up, marginalising the working classes in the country.

The first attempt, launched in February of that year, was commanded by Major Hugo Chávez and sought to make Rafael Caldera president.

Caldera had served already in the role between 1969 and 1974 and had been able to heal many of the divisions that had been tearing Venezuela apart at the time.

However, the coup miscarried, and Chávez was arrested and put in prison. But this didn’t detract from the fact that there was still widespread dissent in the country, nor that Chávez still enjoyed some support in the Venezuelan army. In fact, his public declarations during and at the failure of the coup attempt raised his profile both in the military and with the people of Venezuela.

On November 27, a second coup was launched. This was led by officers from the Air Force and Navy and enjoyed some initial success when they managed to seize some air force bases and a television station.

With the aircraft available and pilots committed to their cause, the rebels launched air attacks on loyalist strongholds, principally army barracks and major police stations. The rebels used Mirage jets, Tucanos and, as seen here, OV-10 Broncos.

The Bronco is an excellent light attack aircraft. Capable of flying at low speeds and altitudes, it was developed in the 1960s by the United States to provide a rugged, simple, close air support aircraft for counterinsurgency. It is also extremely agile. Though, as became apparent, not agile enough.

The rebels initial success began to come apart when loyalist forces launched counterattacks, pushing them from their captured key points. And one of the critical events was a loyalist pilot getting airborne in his F-16 fighter. This is an excellent air combat aircraft that can fly at twice the speed of sound.

Fitted with modem radar and air-to-air missiles, it was the most formidable aircraft in the Venezuelans arsenal in 1992. This led to the graphic demonstration of how an agile prop aircraft can get as low and slow as it can but, at the end of the day, it is just buying time.

To be fair, the Bronco has no real weaponry for fighting back, so it was hardly a fair fight. But if it did, a modern fighter would just stand off and use its better performance to control the fight anyway – unless the pilot was dumb.

The second coup was thwarted and before the end of the day the remaining rebels fled to Peru. The death toll for the attempt was 172. Chávez remained in prison, though only for a few years.

Caldera was elected president in 1994 and released Chávez, who would go on to become President himself in 1999.

But I’d certainly say this incident resolves the “prop vs. jet” debate.

Guns-A-Go-Go; The Boeing Vertol ACH-47A

Guns-A-Go-Go; The Boeing Vertol ACH-47A

The histories of the US intervention in Vietnam generally start in March 1965, when US Marines stormed ashore at Da Nang…to be met by a bevy of Vietnamese beauties holding signs saying: “Welcome Gallant Marines”. But in fact, the United States had been deploying...

Myanmar Military Reeling From Attacks by Anti-Coup Forces

Myanmar Military Reeling From Attacks by Anti-Coup Forces

Well, it is kicking off in Myanmar. Big time. I have occasionally reported on the ongoing conflict in that bighted for years, indeed I’ve even conducted humanitarian work in some of the conflict areas in the country. But I have never seen anything close to what is...

The Long War Pt.5; The Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army

The Long War Pt.5; The Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army

As the conflict in Myanmar, otherwise known as Burma, has seen a lot of important developments recently I thought it might be useful to resume this series on the Ethnic Armed Organizations (EAOs) fighting against the military junta who seized power in a coup in 2021....

Globemaster Mini Me; The McDonnell Douglas YC-15

Globemaster Mini Me; The McDonnell Douglas YC-15

In my previous “Forgotten Aircraft” article I covered Boeing’s YC-14 and talked about how in the early 1970’s the United States Air Force (USAF) had expressed an interest in acquiring a replacement for the Lockheed C-130 Hercules. For this they initiated the Advanced...

Meet the Ratel S Anti-Tank Drone

Meet the Ratel S Anti-Tank Drone

A few years ago I wrote an article, followed up later by a video, about the need for a cheap guided  anti-vehicle-and-position weapon for infantry. My reasoning was that for many years now most militaries have ended up resorting to using anti-tank missiles for this...