“I am not an animal…”; The Short S.B.3

April 5, 2021

Looking like the aircraft equivalent of Joseph Merrick – AKA “the Elephant Man” – the Shorts S.B.3 was a prototype carrier-based anti-submarine aircraft that was the final attempt to get an order for the Short’s Sturgeon.

It is probably not a surprise to learn that such an…unusual looking aircraft was a product of trying to adapt a design over several years of changing specifications. In 1943 and as the tide of World War Two began to turn, the Royal Navy put out a requirement for new carrier torpedo bomber, which Short’s wasn’t invited to tender for, but they did anyway.

Later that year a new specification was issued for a twin-engine naval reconnaissance aircraft which had a secondary attack capability. Again, Short’s entered their design – the Sturgeon – and this time they actually won.

 

The aircraft proposed was a rather neat-looking design, powered by two Merlin engines and capable of carrying ASV radar, cameras or a 1000lb bombload. Thirty were ordered, but then the Second World War ended, and the Navy no longer wanted the Sturgeon.

But production was underway, so they had to figure out what to do with them. Here things began to get ugly – so to speak.

Most of the Sturgeons were converted into TT.2 and ‘.3 target tugs, and these served for a few years. They may not have been great looking, but they did the job.

 

But Short’s still had hopes for the Sturgeon and figured that it might make a carrier anti-sub hunter. So, they took two of the original aircraft in 1949 and created the S.B.3.

 

The aircraft had a deep nose and chin fitted which contained both the surface search radar and a cabin for two operators. This gave the aircraft its distinctive look, but the reasoning for building the aircraft had a lot of sound basis.

The Sturgeon was a proven airframe, capable of operating on at least some of the serving carriers and was ready for production. It wasn’t pretty, but if it could do the job, so what?

That’s where the problem lay. Because the S.B.3 had the original Merlin piston engines replaced by Mamba turboprops. These, combined with the substantial changes to the aircraft layout, changed the handling characteristics of the S.B.3.

 

The aircraft is reported to have been difficult to trim for long flights – important for a patrol plane – and the one flying example made a single demonstration at Farnborough in 1950. There its looks drew some comment, and the test reports on the aircraft’s issues killed the S.B.3. In 1951 both prototypes were scrapped and the Royal Navy proceeded with other designs.

Guns-A-Go-Go; The Boeing Vertol ACH-47A

Guns-A-Go-Go; The Boeing Vertol ACH-47A

The histories of the US intervention in Vietnam generally start in March 1965, when US Marines stormed ashore at Da Nang…to be met by a bevy of Vietnamese beauties holding signs saying: “Welcome Gallant Marines”. But in fact, the United States had been deploying...

Myanmar Military Reeling From Attacks by Anti-Coup Forces

Myanmar Military Reeling From Attacks by Anti-Coup Forces

Well, it is kicking off in Myanmar. Big time. I have occasionally reported on the ongoing conflict in that bighted for years, indeed I’ve even conducted humanitarian work in some of the conflict areas in the country. But I have never seen anything close to what is...

The Long War Pt.5; The Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army

The Long War Pt.5; The Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army

As the conflict in Myanmar, otherwise known as Burma, has seen a lot of important developments recently I thought it might be useful to resume this series on the Ethnic Armed Organizations (EAOs) fighting against the military junta who seized power in a coup in 2021....

Globemaster Mini Me; The McDonnell Douglas YC-15

Globemaster Mini Me; The McDonnell Douglas YC-15

In my previous “Forgotten Aircraft” article I covered Boeing’s YC-14 and talked about how in the early 1970’s the United States Air Force (USAF) had expressed an interest in acquiring a replacement for the Lockheed C-130 Hercules. For this they initiated the Advanced...

Meet the Ratel S Anti-Tank Drone

Meet the Ratel S Anti-Tank Drone

A few years ago I wrote an article, followed up later by a video, about the need for a cheap guided  anti-vehicle-and-position weapon for infantry. My reasoning was that for many years now most militaries have ended up resorting to using anti-tank missiles for this...